Italy's data protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, has issued an €805 million ($887 million) fine against Meta Platforms Ireland Limited. The penalty targets a Facebook for Android feature that automatically scanned photos, videos, and associated metadata directly from local device storage without obtaining explicit consent.
According to regulatory findings first reported by The Hacker News, the watchdog determined that the mechanism violated Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, which transposes the European Union's ePrivacy Directive. The statute treats mobile hardware as an extension of an individual's private sphere, mandating free and informed user permission prior to reading local device storage, regardless of whether data is subsequently exfiltrated or causes direct harm.
Bundled Permissions and Default Gallery Scanning
The regulatory action centers on a capability named "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook," which has been bundled into the Android application since 2023. Rather than requesting explicit opt-in consent for background processing, the application turned the recommendation engine on by default once users granted general media permissions to the broader app.
Investigators discovered that Meta asked for storage access through a single blanket permission covering multiple app features that served completely separate operational purposes. While users were presented with a generic notice outlining other features, the prompt omitted clear disclosures that local photo libraries would be systematically parsed to generate posting suggestions.
Once granted, this broad operating system permission enabled Facebook to read entire photo archives continuously. The Garante noted that neither users nor authorities possessed technical controls to monitor precisely which files and metadata records the application inspected over time.
Scope of the Violation and Enforcement Mandates
The investigation originated in July 2025 following a formal complaint by the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection organization based in Bolzano, Italy. The Garante subsequently conducted its own independent technical analyses of the software's behavior.
The fine accounts for approximately 0.47% of Meta's global turnover, as reported by SecurityWeek. In calculating the penalty, the regulator considered the scale of the infringement, which affected roughly 20 million Android users across Italy, as well as an earlier enforcement ruling against Meta in 2019 and what the authority characterized as limited cooperation during proceedings.
Meta challenged the Garante's authority, arguing that Ireland's Data Protection Commission should serve as the lead supervisor. The Italian watchdog rejected that claim because the ePrivacy Directive framework does not include the General Data Protection Regulation's (GDPR) "one-stop-shop" cross-border mechanism.
The Garante ordered Meta to implement strict corrective remedies:
- Deactivate the feature: Meta must turn off gallery suggestions by default within 60 days, including for users who previously granted broad gallery storage permissions.
- Implement standalone consent: The vendor must build an isolated, transparent prompt explaining the feature's technical function, what it inspects, and how to revoke access.
- Submit compliance reports: Meta must present an interim roadmap to the authority within 30 days and provide full proof of compliance within 90 days.
Failure to meet the 60-day window legally prevents Meta from enabling the feature for any Italian user lacking verified consent. While Meta indicated plans to appeal the penalty, calling the amount disproportionate, the company maintained that gallery features rely on standard operating system permissions that users can modify anytime.
The probe did not evaluate whether photo libraries fed Meta's artificial intelligence training models, which the company denied. However, the regulator noted it may separately evaluate a 2026 feature that processes gallery contents using cloud infrastructure.
What You Should Do
Organizations managing Android endpoints and individual device owners should audit local permission scopes to prevent unrestricted file-system inspection:
- Audit Facebook app settings: Open Facebook, navigate to internal media preferences, locate the setting for gallery suggestions while browsing, and manually toggle it off.
- Restrict Android storage privileges: Open device settings, select application permissions for Facebook, and downgrade storage access from "Allow all the time" to "Don't allow" or limit it strictly to manually selected photos.
- Deploy mobile application management (MAM): Enterprise administrators should utilize mobile management profiles to restrict social media tools from accessing corporate work profiles or native document storage spaces on managed devices.





